8 Reasons Why Asking “What Does This Mean to Me” is Bad for Bible Interpretation
Interpreting the Bible is a complex and nuanced task, and while the phrase "What does this mean to me?" isn't inherently bad, it can lead to potential pitfalls and misunderstandings when used as the sole or primary approach. Here are some reasons why relying solely on this approach can be problematic:
Subjectivity: Interpreting the Bible through the lens of personal relevance can lead to highly subjective interpretations. What is meaningful to one person may not be to another, and this subjectivity can result in a wide range of interpretations that may not align with the text's original intent.
Ignoring Historical and Cultural Context: The Bible was written in specific historical and cultural contexts that may differ significantly from our own. Focusing solely on personal relevance may cause readers to overlook the historical and cultural factors that influenced the text, leading to misinterpretations.
Cherry-picking verses: This approach can lead to cherry-picking verses that align with one's pre-existing beliefs or desires while ignoring other passages that may challenge or provide a broader context for understanding the message of the Bible.
Loss of Depth: The Bible contains layers of meaning, including historical, theological, moral, and spiritual dimensions. Reducing it to a "what does this mean to me" approach may result in a shallow understanding that misses these deeper dimensions.
Self-Centered Interpretation: An exclusive focus on personal relevance may inadvertently reinforce a self-centered perspective, where the Bible becomes primarily about how it benefits the reader rather than seeking to understand God's message and will.
Risk of Misinterpretation: When individuals interpret the Bible primarily based on personal relevance, there is a higher risk of misinterpretation or misapplication of the text, as the original context and intent may be disregarded.
Lack of Accountability: Without considering the broader context of a faith community or the guidance of scholars and theologians, relying solely on personal interpretation can lead to isolation from the collective wisdom of a religious tradition.
Inconsistent Interpretation: If every reader interprets the Bible solely through the "what does this mean to me" lens, it can result in a lack of consistency and cohesion within a religious community, making the establishment of shared beliefs and practices difficult.
It's important to note that personal relevance and application of biblical texts can still be valuable, but it should ideally be balanced with a more balanced approach to interpretation that considers historical context, literary analysis, theological principles, and the wisdom of orthodox religious traditions. This allows for a richer and more accurate understanding of the Bible's message and its significance in one's life.
If you find this blog helpful and want to say thanks, click here to buy Danny Davis a coffee.
